Justia U.S. 8th Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries
Articles Posted in Energy, Oil & Gas Law
WPX Energy Williston, LLC v. Jones
WPX Energy, a non-Indian oil and gas company, obtained rights-of-way from the Bureau of Indian Affairs to access land owned by members of the Three Affiliated Tribes on the Fort Berthold Reservation. The Fettigs, tribal members and landowners, consented to the grants and also entered into side letter agreements with WPX Energy, imposing conditions such as prohibiting smoking and hunting, and specifying fines for violations. In 2020, the Fettigs filed suit in the Three Affiliated Tribes District Court, alleging WPX Energy violated the no-smoking provision. WPX Energy argued that the tribal court lacked jurisdiction, as it is a non-Indian entity, but the tribal district court, through Judge Jones, found it had jurisdiction under the Montana consensual relationship exception. The Fettigs also pursued an administrative claim with the Bureau, which was denied on the basis that the side letter agreements were not incorporated into the grants.WPX Energy sought a preliminary injunction in the United States District Court for the District of North Dakota, claiming the tribal court lacked jurisdiction. The district court granted the injunction, but the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit previously vacated it, requiring exhaustion of tribal remedies. After the Three Affiliated Tribes Supreme Court affirmed tribal jurisdiction, WPX Energy again sought relief in federal court, which again granted a preliminary injunction. Judge Jones appealed this second grant.On review, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit held that the tribal court had jurisdiction under the first Montana exception because the dispute arose from a commercial relationship created by the side letter agreements, which were independently negotiated and not governed by federal law. The court also found that normal litigation costs did not constitute irreparable harm. The Eighth Circuit vacated the preliminary injunction and remanded for further proceedings. View "WPX Energy Williston, LLC v. Jones" on Justia Law
United States v. Smith
In May 2023, law enforcement officers in North Dakota responded to a report of gunshots fired into electrical equipment at a substation owned by two power cooperatives. Near the scene, officers searched a car and found a gun case and medication labeled with Cameron Smith’s name. A tow truck employee identified Smith as the driver and indicated he had dropped Smith off at a nearby hotel. Officers located Smith at the hotel, detained him, and obtained surveillance footage showing him with duffel bags later found in a dumpster. The bags contained firearms and ammunition matching shell casings at the substation. Officers obtained warrants to test the bags for DNA and to search Smith’s residence and devices. Smith was charged with destruction of an energy facility in North Dakota and later in South Dakota for a similar incident.The United States District Court for the District of North Dakota denied Smith’s motion to suppress evidence, ruling that the evidence would have been inevitably discovered even absent the challenged searches. Smith then entered a conditional guilty plea, reserving his right to appeal the suppression ruling. At sentencing, the district court applied a 12-level upward departure under the sentencing guidelines and imposed consecutive sentences totaling 300 months, plus over $2 million in restitution.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed the denial of Smith’s motion to suppress, finding that the modified warrant affidavit supported probable cause and that the evidence was admissible under the inevitable discovery doctrine. The court also concluded that Smith’s appeal waiver barred his challenge to the restitution order. However, the appellate court found procedural error in the calculation of the sentencing guideline range, holding that the evidence did not support a finding that Smith’s motive was to intimidate or coerce a civilian population as required for the sentencing departure. The court vacated the sentence and remanded for resentencing. View "United States v. Smith" on Justia Law
Pennington v. BHP Billiton Petrol
Owners of mineral interests in Arkansas leased their interests to various oil and gas companies through private agreements. These leases required the companies to pay royalties based on gross proceeds, meaning royalties should be calculated without deducting post-production costs. In 2019, Flywheel, the operator for these leases, began deducting post-production costs from the first 1/8 royalty payment, relying on Ark. Code Ann. § 15-72-305, which refers to “net proceeds.” This change reduced the royalty amounts paid to the lessors, who then filed suit alleging breach of lease obligations.The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas reviewed the claims and granted summary judgment in favor of the oil and gas companies. The district court interpreted Ark. Code Ann. § 15-72-305 to permit deductions of post-production expenses from the first 1/8 royalty, regardless of lease terms. It relied on its own prior rulings and declined to follow an Arkansas Court of Appeals decision stating that the statute does not require deduction of post-production expenses. The district court also considered but ultimately rejected the impact of a legislative amendment, Act 1024, passed during the appeal, which clarified the meaning of “net proceeds.”The United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit reviewed the district court’s interpretation of Arkansas law de novo. The appellate court held that Ark. Code Ann. § 15-72-305(a)(3) is ambiguous regarding permissible deductions and determined, based on legislative clarification and the Arkansas Court of Appeals’ interpretation, that deductions from the royalty are not allowed beyond those specifically permitted by the lease. The court concluded that Act 1024 clarified the original legislative intent. It reversed the district court’s summary judgment and remanded for further proceedings consistent with its interpretation. View "Pennington v. BHP Billiton Petrol" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Energy, Oil & Gas Law
Murphy v. Continental Resources, Inc.
The case concerns disputes between two groups of North Dakota surface landowners and an oil and gas company with rights to drill on their land. After the company gave statutory notice and commenced drilling, the landowners and the company were unable to reach an agreement on compensation for damages to the land, as required by North Dakota’s Oil and Gas Production Damage Compensation Act. Both sets of landowners, represented by the same law firm, filed separate lawsuits in federal court seeking compensation for damages. The cases involved substantial litigation over discovery, scheduling, expert witnesses, and attorneys’ fees, with mediation attempts failing. Eventually, the parties reached stipulated judgments settling the claims for monetary amounts.After settlement, the landowners sought attorneys’ fees under North Dakota law, submitting discounted requests and supporting invoices. The company objected, arguing that the requests were excessive given the simplicity of the dispute and raising concerns such as alleged excessive billing, duplicative work, and poor documentation. The company also requested an in-person hearing on the fee motions, which was denied.The United States District Court for the District of North Dakota applied the lodestar method to determine reasonable attorneys’ fees, starting with the actual fees incurred, then reducing the amounts based on factors such as poor documentation and litigation conduct. The court awarded the landowners more than they requested, after finding the hourly rates and the time expended reasonable, but applying a 10% reduction for documentation issues and delays. The court also denied the company’s motion for oral argument.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed. The court held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in its fee award calculations, its consideration of relevant factors, or in denying an oral argument. The court found that the district court’s approach and reductions were consistent with precedent and North Dakota law. View "Murphy v. Continental Resources, Inc." on Justia Law
Posted in:
Energy, Oil & Gas Law
Missouri River Energy Services v. FERC
Missouri River Energy Services provides electricity to municipal utilities in several Midwest states and joined the Southwest Power Pool, an independent regional transmission organization, in October 2015. Prior to Missouri River’s integration, Southwest Power Pool had already allocated all available long-term firm transmission rights, which are financial instruments designed to protect load-serving entities from congestion charges on the transmission grid. Since joining, Missouri River has requested long-term transmission rights but has not received any, because existing rights holders had already claimed the available capacity.After repeatedly receiving no long-term rights, Missouri River filed a complaint with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) in 2023. Missouri River argued that the allocations by Southwest Power Pool violated both the governing tariff and FERC’s Order No. 681, and that FERC’s rejection of its complaint was arbitrary and capricious. FERC denied the complaint, finding no violation of the tariff or Order No. 681, and determined that Missouri River was not entitled to a specific allocation of long-term rights under federal law or the tariff.Missouri River then sought review in the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit. The court held that the Federal Power Act and Order No. 681 require that long-term transmission rights be made available to the class of load-serving entities, but do not guarantee individual entities such as Missouri River a specific allocation. The court further concluded that Southwest Power Pool had properly implemented its tariff, including the simultaneous feasibility test and procedures for handling parallel flows and shift factors, and that FERC’s decision was supported by substantial evidence. The Eighth Circuit denied Missouri River’s petition for review, upholding FERC’s order. View "Missouri River Energy Services v. FERC" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Energy, Oil & Gas Law
Chase v. Andeavor Logistics, L.P.
A group of individuals with beneficial interests in Indian trust lands on the Fort Berthold Reservation in North Dakota challenged the continued operation of an oil pipeline by Andeavor Logistics and related entities after the expiration of a federally granted right-of-way in 2013. Despite the expiration, Andeavor continued to operate the pipeline while negotiating for renewals with both the tribal government and individual landowners, but was unable to secure agreements with all landowners. The plaintiffs, known as the Allottees, alleged ongoing trespass, breach of the expired easement agreement, and unjust enrichment, seeking monetary damages, injunctive relief, and removal of the pipeline.The United States District Court for the District of North Dakota twice dismissed the Allottees’ case, first for failure to exhaust administrative remedies, a decision reversed by the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit in a prior appeal (Chase I), which instructed a stay for further agency action. After further BIA proceedings and related litigation (including the Tesoro case), the district court again dismissed all of the Allottees’ claims with prejudice, finding no individual federal common law cause of action for trespass, breach of contract, or unjust enrichment, and denied their motion to intervene in the Tesoro case, concluding the United States adequately represented their interests.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed the district court’s dismissal of the Allottees’ claims for trespass, breach of contract, and unjust enrichment, holding that individual Indian allottees with only equitable interests in land held in trust by the United States lack standing to bring these claims under federal common law. The court also affirmed denial of intervention in the Tesoro litigation. However, the Eighth Circuit remanded for further consideration of whether consolidation of the two related cases is appropriate under Rule 42(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. View "Chase v. Andeavor Logistics, L.P." on Justia Law
State of Iowa v. Wright
The case concerns a challenge to a 2024 rule issued by the Department of Energy (DOE) that revised the method for calculating the “petroleum equivalency factor” (PEF), which is used to determine the fuel economy values of electric vehicles for regulatory purposes. The DOE had previously used a “fuel content factor” of 1/0.15, which significantly inflated the fuel economy ratings of electric vehicles. In its 2023 proposal, DOE suggested eliminating this factor, but in the final rule, it opted to phase it out gradually over several model years. The final rule also introduced a new method for calculating the PEF, using a “cumulative gasoline-equivalent fuel economy of electricity” based on the projected useful life of an electric vehicle fleet—a method not included in the proposed rule.Several states and the American Free Enterprise Chamber of Commerce petitioned for review in the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit. They argued that the DOE exceeded its statutory authority by retaining the fuel content factor and violated notice-and-comment requirements by adopting a new calculation method not previously proposed. The petitioners asserted standing based on increased costs to maintain public roads due to heavier electric vehicles and environmental harms from increased greenhouse gas emissions.The Eighth Circuit found that the petitioners had standing and that the case was not moot, even in light of new EPA emissions standards. The court held that DOE exceeded its statutory authority by retaining the fuel content factor, as the relevant statute did not authorize such an approach. Additionally, the court determined that DOE violated notice-and-comment procedures by failing to provide adequate notice of the new cumulative calculation method. The court concluded that these deficiencies were not severable from the rest of the rule.Accordingly, the Eighth Circuit granted the petition for review, vacated the 2024 final rule, and remanded the matter to DOE. View "State of Iowa v. Wright" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Energy, Oil & Gas Law, Government & Administrative Law
MBI Oil and Gas, LLC v. Royalty Interests Partnership, LP
In 2013, Royalty Interests Partnership, LP (Royalty) leased oil and gas drilling rights to MBI Oil & Gas, LLC (MBI) for a primary term of three years, with the lease continuing as long as oil and gas production occurred on the leased premises or pooled acreage. By 2016, MBI had not drilled any wells or paid royalties, although one pre-existing well was producing oil and gas. In 2020, Royalty leased the same premises to Ovintiv USA Inc. (Ovintiv), which drilled several wells. In 2022, Royalty requested MBI to release its lease, but MBI refused and initiated litigation, claiming its lease was still valid.The United States District Court for the District of North Dakota granted summary judgment in favor of Royalty and Grayson Mill Bakken, LLC (Grayson Mill), Ovintiv’s successor. The court found that MBI had failed to extend the lease term by not producing oil and gas on the leased premises. MBI appealed this decision.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit reviewed the case. The court held that the reservation clause in the lease unambiguously reserved all rights to the production from the pre-existing well to Royalty, excluding it from perpetuating the lease. The court also found that North Dakota’s pooling statute was inapplicable because it applies to separately owned tracts, not separately owned interests in the same tract. Consequently, the court affirmed the district court’s decision, concluding that MBI’s lease had expired due to its failure to produce oil and gas or contribute to drilling on the leased premises or pooled acreage. View "MBI Oil and Gas, LLC v. Royalty Interests Partnership, LP" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Energy, Oil & Gas Law
Continental Resources, Inc. v. United States
Continental Resources, Inc., an oil and gas production company, leases minerals from both the North Dakota Board of University and School Lands (Land Board) and the United States. The dispute centers on the entitlement to royalties from minerals extracted from the bed of Lake Sakakawea in North Dakota, which depends on the location of the Ordinary High Water Mark (OHWM). If North Dakota law and the state survey govern the OHWM, the Land Board is entitled to a larger percentage of the royalties; if the federal survey controls, the United States is entitled to a larger percentage.The United States removed the interpleader action to federal court and moved to dismiss based on sovereign immunity. The United States District Court for the District of North Dakota denied the motion, holding that under 28 U.S.C. § 2410(a)(5), the United States waived sovereign immunity because North Dakota law created a lien in favor of the United States upon Continental severing the minerals. The district court granted summary judgment in favor of the United States for lands retained since North Dakota's admission to the Union, applying federal law and the Corps Survey. It granted summary judgment in favor of the Land Board for lands reacquired by the United States, applying North Dakota law and the Wenck survey.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit reviewed the case. It affirmed the district court's denial of the motion to dismiss, agreeing that the United States had a lien on the disputed minerals under North Dakota law. The court also affirmed the summary judgment in favor of the Land Board, holding that North Dakota law governs the current location of the OHWM for lands reacquired by the United States. The court denied the United States' motion for judicial notice of additional documents. View "Continental Resources, Inc. v. United States" on Justia Law
Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc. v. Southwest Power Pool, Inc.
During Winter Storm Uri, Southwest Power Pool, Inc. (Southwest) contacted Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc. (the Cooperative) to purchase emergency energy. The Cooperative provided the energy, and Southwest compensated the Cooperative according to their existing written contract, known as the Tariff, filed with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). The Cooperative claimed the payment was insufficient and not in line with a separate oral agreement made during the storm. Southwest refused to pay more than the Tariff rate, leading the Cooperative to file a lawsuit in federal district court for breach of contract and equitable claims.Southwest petitioned FERC for a declaratory order asserting primary jurisdiction over the dispute and confirming that the payment was appropriate under the Tariff. FERC agreed, and the Cooperative's petition for rehearing was denied. The Cooperative then sought review from the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, which denied the petitions, affirming FERC's primary jurisdiction and the applicability of the Tariff rate.The United States District Court for the Western District of Missouri granted Southwest’s motion to dismiss the Cooperative’s complaint, agreeing with FERC’s jurisdiction and the Tariff’s control over the payment terms. The district court also denied Southwest’s motion for attorneys’ fees and costs. The Cooperative appealed the dismissal, and Southwest appealed the denial of attorneys’ fees.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit reviewed the district court’s dismissal de novo and affirmed the decision, agreeing that FERC had primary jurisdiction and the Tariff controlled the payment terms. The court also affirmed the district court’s denial of attorneys’ fees, finding that the relevant contract provision did not apply to this dispute and that the district court did not abuse its discretion. View "Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc. v. Southwest Power Pool, Inc." on Justia Law